Motion - Phosphates
Motion or resolution considered by Powys County Council
This motion was heard on 20/07/2023. It was proposed by Gareth Ratcliffe and seconded by Corinna Kenyon-Wade .
Compare this vote to another vote »
Motion as voted upon
This council and neighbouring authorities in Wales and England have faced severe planning restrictions due to the phosphate levels within our rivers. This is a national issue that is being passed around, and communities are being divided on who is responsible and how to deal with the issue.
We have heard numerous times that high concentrations of phosphorus in our rivers are due to agricultural practices, runoff from urban areas, leaking septic systems or discharges from sewage treatment plants, to name just a few that the public is citing as the cause. All of these systems are mainly operating within the laws that were granted to them, and that allows them to discharge into our rivers. We need to acknowledge they are operating within the rules set by the national government.
Whilst individually such developments are of minimal impact, collectively they cause massive damage to our environment, and impact the housing shortage issue facing our county as well as other developments.
We look at Natural Resources Wales, which, as the manager of our natural Welsh resources, should monitor our rivers. Its purpose is to "pursue sustainable management of natural resources†and “apply the principles of sustainable management of natural resources†as stated in the Environment (Wales) Act 2016.
The proper monitoring of water quality, and the enforcement of new environmental policy is going to be key in reducing the impact of phosphates on our rivers. NRW is said to need to employ an extra 85 staff to achieve the necessary robust monitoring service, but they need the funding from Welsh Government to be able to do this. Powys County Council itself does not have the power or capacity to effect change. Homes are not being built, communities in Powys are at a standstill, and something needs to be done to support them.
The motion
1. We call on the Welsh Government to set a clear monitoring framework for river pollution.
2. We call on National Governments to accelerate funding for our monitoring bodies like NRW to allow them to monitor and enforce safe levels within our rivers.
3. Call on Welsh Water to accelerate its investment in the sewage system and their upgrade programme.
Result: Passed
Vote Type: normal
Voting Summary
Below is a summary of the votes for, against, abstain or did not vote for the motion. Councillors are displayed by their party colours - please hover over the block to view the councillor.
For: 51
Against: 0
Abstain: 0
Did Not Vote: 17
Voting Record
Below is the individual voting record for all councillors on this motion/resolution.
Name | Group | Vote | |
---|---|---|---|
Baynham, Beverley Presteigne |
Powys Independents | Did not vote | |
Bebb, Danny Churchstoke |
Welsh Liberal Democrat Group | For | |
Beecham, Matt Crickhowell with Cwmdu and Tretower |
Resigned | For | |
Beecham, Sarah-Jane Crickhowell with Cwmdu and Tretower |
Resigned | For | |
Berriman, Jake Llandrindod North |
Welsh Liberal Democrat Group | For | |
Breeze, Ben Kerry |
Welsh Conservatives Group | For | |
Breeze, Graham Welshpool Llanerchyddol |
Powys Independents | For | |
Brighouse, Little Disserth and Trecoed with Newbridge |
Non-Affiliated | For | |
Brignell-Thorp, Jeremy Forden and Montgomery |
Non-Affiliated | For | |
Cartwright, Anita Talybont-on-Usk |
Resigned | Did not vote | |
Charlton, Jackie Llangattock and Llangynidr |
Welsh Liberal Democrat Group | For | |
Church, Richard Welshpool Castle |
Welsh Liberal Democrat Group | For | |
Colbert, Tom Bronllys and Felin-fach |
Non-Affiliated | For | |
Cox, Sian Llangors with Bwlch |
Welsh Liberal Democrat Group | For | |
Davies, Aled Llanrhaeadr-ym-Mochnant and Llansilin |
Welsh Conservatives Group | For | |
Davies, Angela Rhayader |
Welsh Liberal Democrat Group | For | |
Davies, Bryan Llanafanfawr with Garth |
Powys Independents | For | |
Davies, Bryn Banwy, Llanfihangel and Llanwddyn |
Plaid Cymru Group | Did not vote | |
Davies, Sandra Cwm-twrch |
Welsh Labour Group | For | |
Dorrance, Matthew Brecon West |
Welsh Labour Group | For | |
Edwards, Deb Llangunllo with Norton |
Powys Independents | For | |
Ewing, Josie Llandrindod South |
Welsh Liberal Democrat Group | For | |
George, Les Caersws |
Welsh Conservatives Group | Did not vote | |
Gibson-Watt, James Glasbury |
Welsh Liberal Democrat Group | Did not vote | |
Harrison, Ian Guilsfield |
Welsh Conservatives Group | For | |
Healy, Kelly Newtown Central and South |
Welsh Liberal Democrat Group | For | |
Hulme, Heulwen Rhiwcynon |
Resigned | For | |
James, Peter Llanwrtyd Wells |
Powys Independents | For | |
Jenner, Amanda Trelystan and Trewern |
Welsh Conservatives Group | Did not vote | |
Johnson-Wood, Claire Llanyre with Nantmel |
Powys Independents | Did not vote | |
Jones, Adrian Berriew and Castle Caereinion |
Welsh Conservatives Group | For | |
Jones, Arwel Llandysilio |
Powys Independents | Did not vote | |
Jones, Ed Old Radnor |
Powys Independents | Did not vote | |
Jones, Gareth D Llanfair Caereinion and Llanerfyl |
Powys Independents | For | |
Jones, Gareth E Llanelwedd |
Powys Independents | For | |
Jones, Joy Newtown East |
Powys Independents | For | |
Kennerley, Adam Newtown North |
Welsh Liberal Democrat Group | For | |
Kenyon-Wade, Corinna Knighton with Beguildy |
Welsh Liberal Democrat Group | For | |
Lewington, Pete Newtown West |
Welsh Conservatives Group | For | |
Lewis, Karl Llandinam with Dolfor |
Welsh Conservatives Group | Did not vote | |
Lewis, Peter Llanfyllin |
Welsh Conservatives Group | Did not vote | |
Lloyd, William Gwernyfed |
Welsh Liberal Democrat Group | For | |
McIntosh, Iain Yscir with Honddu Isaf and Llanddew |
Welsh Conservatives Group | For | |
McNicholas, Susan Ynyscedwyn |
Welsh Labour Group | For | |
Meredith, David Brecon West |
Welsh Labour Group | For | |
Mitchell, Gary Llanbrynmair |
Plaid Cymru Group | Did not vote | |
Morgan, Gareth Llanidloes |
Welsh Liberal Democrat Group | Did not vote | |
Morgan, Geoff Ithon Valley |
Powys Independents | For | |
Powell, William Talgarth |
Welsh Liberal Democrat Group | For | |
Preston, Glyn Llanidloes |
Welsh Liberal Democrat Group | Did not vote | |
Pugh, Gareth Dolforwyn |
Welsh Conservatives Group | For | |
Pugh, Jeremy Builth |
Powys Independents | Did not vote | |
Ratcliffe, Gareth Hay |
Welsh Liberal Democrat Group | For | |
Rijnenberg, Liz Brecon East |
Welsh Labour Group | For | |
Roberts, Lucy Llandrinio |
Welsh Conservatives Group | For | |
Roberts, Pete Llandrindod South |
Welsh Liberal Democrat Group | For | |
Robinson, Carol Welshpool Gungrog |
Welsh Liberal Democrat Group | For | |
Roderick, Edwin Maescar and Llywel |
Powys Independents | Did not vote | |
Selby, David Newtown Central and South |
Welsh Liberal Democrat Group | For | |
Thomas, David Tawe Uchaf |
Welsh Labour Group | For | |
Thomas, Gwynfor Llansantffraid |
Welsh Conservatives Group | For | |
Vaughan, Elwyn Glantwymyn |
Plaid Cymru Group | Did not vote | |
Walsh, Chris Brecon East |
Welsh Labour Group | For | |
Wilkinson, Jonathan Llangyniew and Meifod |
Welsh Conservatives Group | For | |
Williams, Ange Knighton with Beguildy |
Powys Independents | For | |
Williams, Huw Aber-craf and Ystradgynlais |
Welsh Labour Group | For | |
Williams, Michael Machynlleth |
Died | For | |
Williams, Sarah Aber-craf and Ystradgynlais |
Welsh Labour Group | For |
Source: Voting Record