Responsible Afforestation
Motion or resolution considered by Powys County Council
This motion was heard on 03/03/2022. It was proposed by Elwyn Vaughan and seconded by Bryn Davies .
Compare this vote to another vote »
Motion as voted upon
Council expresses its concern about the purchase of family farms in Powys and the wider region by multinational companies to plant trees for the purpose of creating ‘carbon credits’ which are sold to polluting companies to meet their carbon offset targets.
While accepting that tree planting on a large scale is recognised as one means of combating climate change, Council regrets that carbon offsetting allows these high carbon-emitting companies to continue with their unsustainable conduct.
Furthermore, Council notes that multinational companies have already claimed over £1.3m from Welsh Government funding via the Glastir Woodland Creation fund, which means that Welsh taxpayers are subsidising the carbon offsetting programmes of companies from outside Wales.
Council supports the principle of responsible afforestation but believes this must be done in consultation with local communities, and should not have a detrimental impact on local employment, culture and community viability.
Council calls on the Welsh Government to
· Ensure that multinational companies who purchase farms to plant trees for the purpose of creating ‘carbon credits’ which are sold to polluting companies to meet their carbon offset targets are not subsidised by Welsh taxpayers.
· Introduce planning development legislation to enable local planning authorities such as Powys to control afforestation projects, and to set a limit on the proportion of land on any farm that can be used for afforestation without the need for planning consent
· Deliver its afforestation plans by developing a publicly owned arms-length company to manage Wales’ forestry and help reach the Welsh Government’s carbon reduction targets
Council recognises the opinion of environmental campaigners that tree planting is not a silver bullet to averting climate change and agrees that only rapid reduction of burning fossil fuels can halt the ongoing and alarming rise in global temperatures.
Result: Passed
Vote Type: normal
Voting Summary
Below is a summary of the votes for, against, abstain or did not vote for the motion. Councillors are displayed by their party colours - please hover over the block to view the councillor.
For: 22
Against: 2
Abstain: 1
Did Not Vote: 48
Voting Record
Below is the individual voting record for all councillors on this motion/resolution.
Name | Group | Vote | |
---|---|---|---|
Alexander, Myfanwy Banwy |
Independent Group | For | |
Barnes, Mark Newtown Llanllwchaiarn West |
Non-Aligned | Did not vote | |
Baynham, Beverley Presteigne |
Powys Independents | For | |
Berriman, Jake Llandrindod North |
Welsh Liberal Democrat Group | Did not vote | |
Breeze, Graham Welshpool Llanerchyddol |
Powys Independents | For | |
Charlton, Jackie Llangattock and Llangynidr |
Welsh Liberal Democrat Group | For | |
Corfield, Linda Forden |
Independent Group | Did not vote | |
Curry, Kelvyn Rhayader |
Welsh Liberal Democrats | Did not vote | |
Davies, Aled Llanrhaeadr-ym-Mochnant and Llansilin |
Welsh Conservatives Group | Did not vote | |
Davies, Bryn Banwy, Llanfihangel and Llanwddyn |
Plaid Cymru Group | Did not vote | |
Davies, Dai Berriew |
Independent Group | Did not vote | |
Davies, Phyl Blaen Hafren |
Welsh Conservatives | For | |
Davies, Sandra Cwm-twrch |
Welsh Labour Group | Did not vote | |
Dorrance, Matthew Brecon West |
Welsh Labour Group | For | |
Durrant, Emily Llangors |
Plaid Cymru | Did not vote | |
Evans, David Nantmel |
Independent Group | Did not vote | |
Evans, James Gwernyfed |
Welsh Conservatives | Did not vote | |
Fitzpatrick, Liam Talybont-on-Usk |
New Powys Group | Did not vote | |
George, Les Caersws |
Welsh Conservatives Group | Did not vote | |
Gibson-Watt, James Glasbury |
Welsh Liberal Democrat Group | For | |
Harris, Rosemarie Llangynidr |
Independent Group | Did not vote | |
Hayes, Stephen Montgomery |
Independent Group | Did not vote | |
Hulme, Heulwen Rhiwcynon |
Resigned | For | |
Jenner, Amanda Trelystan and Trewern |
Welsh Conservatives Group | For | |
Jones-Poston, Diane Llanbrynmair |
Welsh Conservatives | Did not vote | |
Jones, Arwel Llandysilio |
Powys Independents | Did not vote | |
Jones, David Guilsfield |
Independent Group | Did not vote | |
Jones, E. Michael Old Radnor |
Independent Group | Did not vote | |
Jones, Emyr Llanfihangel |
Independent Group | Did not vote | |
Did not vote | |||
Jones, Joy Newtown East |
Powys Independents | Did not vote | |
Jones, Michael J Churchstoke |
Independent Group | Did not vote | |
Jump, Francesca Welshpool Gungrog |
Welsh Liberal Democrats | Abstained | |
Laurie-Parry, Karen Bronllys |
New Powys Group | Did not vote | |
Lewis, Hywel Llangunllo |
Independent Group | For | |
Lewis, Karl Llandinam with Dolfor |
Welsh Conservatives Group | Did not vote | |
Lewis, Peter Llanfyllin |
Welsh Conservatives Group | Did not vote | |
Mackenzie, Maureen Llanelwedd |
Welsh Liberal Democrats | For | |
McIntosh, Iain Yscir with Honddu Isaf and Llanddew |
Welsh Conservatives Group | For | |
McNicholas, Susan Ynyscedwyn |
Welsh Labour Group | For | |
Meredith, David Brecon West |
Welsh Labour Group | For | |
Against | |||
Morgan, Gareth Llanidloes |
Welsh Liberal Democrat Group | For | |
Morris, John Crickhowell |
Welsh Liberal Democrats | Did not vote | |
Powell, Rachel Beguildy |
Independent Group | Did not vote | |
Powell, William Talgarth |
Welsh Liberal Democrat Group | Did not vote | |
Price, David Llanafanfawr |
Independent Group | Did not vote | |
Pritchard, Phil Welshpool Castle |
Independent Group | For | |
Pugh, Gareth Dolforwyn |
Welsh Conservatives Group | Did not vote | |
Pugh, Jeremy Builth |
Powys Independents | Did not vote | |
Ratcliffe, Gareth Hay |
Welsh Liberal Democrat Group | For | |
Rijnenberg, Liz Brecon East |
Welsh Labour Group | For | |
Roberts-Jones, Kath Kerry |
Independent Group | For | |
Roberts, Lucy Llandrinio |
Welsh Conservatives Group | Did not vote | |
Roberts, Pete Llandrindod South |
Welsh Liberal Democrat Group | For | |
Roderick, Edwin Maescar and Llywel |
Powys Independents | Did not vote | |
Rowlands, Daniel Newtown Llanllwchaiarn North |
Welsh Conservatives | Did not vote | |
Selby, David Newtown Central and South |
Welsh Liberal Democrat Group | For | |
Silk, Kathryn Bwlch |
Welsh Liberal Democrats | Did not vote | |
Skilton, Les Newtown South |
Action for Powys Group | Against | |
Thomas, David Tawe Uchaf |
Welsh Labour Group | Did not vote | |
Thomas, Gwynfor Llansantffraid |
Welsh Conservatives Group | Did not vote | |
Van-Rees, Tim Llanwrtyd Wells |
Independent Group | Did not vote | |
Vaughan, Elwyn Glantwymyn |
Plaid Cymru Group | Did not vote | |
Weale, Martin Llanbadarn Fawr |
Action for Powys Group | Did not vote | |
Wilkinson, Jonathan Llangyniew and Meifod |
Welsh Conservatives Group | Did not vote | |
Williams, Ange Knighton with Beguildy |
Powys Independents | Did not vote | |
Williams, Gwilym Disserth and Trecoed |
Action for Powys Group | Did not vote | |
Williams, Huw Aber-craf and Ystradgynlais |
Welsh Labour Group | For | |
Williams, Jon Llandrindod East/Llandrindod West |
Non-Aligned | Did not vote | |
Williams, Michael Machynlleth |
Died | Did not vote | |
Williams, Roger Felin-Fach |
Welsh Liberal Democrats | Did not vote | |
Williams, Sarah Aber-craf and Ystradgynlais |
Welsh Labour Group | Did not vote |
Source: Voting Record